Hi Strumelia,
'Being sure' is a relative idea
In the above example starting at the open melody string playing Ionian means using the 6+ fret, right? (Rob writes about 'a nice major sounding mode') Using the 6+ and shifting the keyboard one fret to the right delivers, still using the 6+ fret, a Dorian mode...
Playing the open string and using the 6 fret (not 6+) delivers first a Mixolydian mode and shifted one position delivers an Aeolian mode. That is what we do by tuning the melody string to C (one down) and start at the first position instead of the open string.
Using a capoon the first fret delivers E Aeolian, a minor scale (not mode), as Aeolian being next to Mixolydian in the circle. Next to Ionian is Dorian.
Ionian > Dorian > Phrygian > Lydian > Mixolydian > Aeolian > Locrian
My opinion isthat talking about modes is confusing and also frustrating, special when learning the dulcimer. Let's only talk about major and minor,and sometimes about Mixolydian and Dorian;almost rarities becausethat is just a few compared with the other two in music. (With exception of the Medieval Church music)
Strumelia said:
Wout are you sure about that?
Wout Blommers said:
Hi Rob,
Tuning in 1-5-8 and starting 1 fret higher will be Dorian.
Wout