Confusion over Rueben's Train
General mountain dulcimer or music discussions
Perhaps it's in the ear of the listener whether they're the same tunes or not? I hear them as two different takes (genres/styles) on the same basic tune (in the Reuben's Train/ 900 Miles family).
When I am learning an old-time/traditional tune to play on mountain dulcimer, I, likely, will listen to fiddle and/or banjo versions then translate the tune to mountain dulcimer. A big part of my music education is and has always been listening to different versions such as you've presented here, @canadian-dulcimer-boy, and figuring out where I hear the essence of the tune (absent ornamentation) and translating that to mountain dulcimer. It's a fun process.
Great thread, @canadian-dulcimer-boy !