Old red stain dulcimer
Instruments- discuss specific features, luthiers, instrument problems & questions
I surfed and saw recent prices from about $50 to about $150. Bottom line is that used dulcimers are worth what someone is willing to pay for them.
I play Noter & Drone and didn't really notice the action being overly high. This was 7 or 8 years ago, when I was out in the Pacific.
As far as other things to check. Unless you've got perfect pitch I would just play the DAd and DAA scales and see how they sound to your ear. The fretboard should be good in that respect, Hondo were good 'true' instruments, not like some of the First Act and other eastern European trash dulcimers that showed up here a decade ago. Play a couple tunes. Do they sound right? No it does not sound like your dulcimer. No two instruments do sound alike. But do the notes in a tune sound 'right'. Do the scales sound true, not sour.
If the price is under $150, I think you're over-thinking the whole 'get a new dulcimer' process. If there are no obvious cracks or major dings, and the scale sounds true, just buy it. Frets can be leveled, actions adjusted, other tweaks made once you've got it home.
Personally I wouldn't worry at this point about fret level, but yes, you use a steel straight edge/rule about 6" long and stand the edge along the frets and see if the straight edge rocks or not. If you sight down the fretboard, dulcimer fretboards are often in a very gently curve with the middle around teh 7th fret being slightly shallower than the ends, but that's OK as long as the notes sound true.
marg:
...this dulcimer.... couldn't have been played very much. That's 35 + years and there is no unusual wear, hardly any wear at all and no damage that I can see. Hard to believe it could be that old. Question than, why wasn't it played?... The price is lower than a few groceries, not sure why I haven't just gotten it and started making it mine... I don't like feeling so unsure, is it because I am still very new and don't know enough?
Lots of dulcimers (even expensive ones) get bought on a whim, and shoved in a closet for a decade or more; unfortunately. I've seen it with $50 cardboard dulcimers and several hundred dollar Warren May and Homer Ledford instruments. Many players baby their instruments and so there aren't any 'honorable scars'.
I suspect your unsureness is simply lack of experience. Did you agonize like this over your first dulcimer?