Any banjo players out there?
Adventures with 'other' instruments...
Bess, for that tune (from an old WV Hammons family recording) I was playing in clawhammer style. Other times I play in minstrel style and tuning. Even though the two styles have a lot in common and can look like the same thing to an observer, I do find the actual physical playing styles of clawhammer and minstrel banjo to be different in significant ways other than simply because they use different tunings. It took me a few years to actually notice that there were these differences. To this day it takes me a minute or so to mentally/physically adjust when I switch back and forth between those two styles of playing. There are always some moments of "Uh, what the heck are my fingers supposed to be doing, again?"... lolol.
I do suggest that a beginner decide which of the two styles to concentrate on for a while, rather than jumping back and forth between clawhammer style/tunings, and minstrel style/tunings. Mixing the two up could be problematic unless you've had at least a year or two of playing one style before exploring the other style. It's possible to learn both styles at the same time as a beginner of course, but the result would very likely be a hybrid style, so you have to decide on what your personal goal is.
If you mostly just play alone at home or with family you can play however you like without worrying about styles at all. But if you plan to play with other folks that seriously play one of those styles and not the other, it might not be the best idea to jump into their established jamming group and start playing their customary repertoire in a hybrid style. ;) Playing in groups means we try to blend harmoniously and enhance what the group likes to do, rather than sticking out and possibly disrupting what they like to do.
updated by @strumelia: 02/21/20 12:01:08PM